Navigating PPSA Complexities for Specific Asset Classes in Australia | GRM LAW

Navigating PPSA Complexities for Specific Asset Classes in Australia

Introduction

The Personal Property Securities Act 2009 (Cth) (PPSA) governs how security interests in personal property are created, prioritised, and enforced in Australia. It represents a significant shift from previous state-based laws, establishing a unified national regime. For private credit providers and borrowers, understanding the nuances of the PPSA, particularly concerning different asset classes, is crucial for effective risk management and structuring transactions. This guide explores the complexities of navigating the PPSA for key asset classes commonly encountered in Australian private credit deals.

Understanding Perfection and Priority

Under the PPSA, a security interest must be "perfected" to ensure its priority against other competing interests and to protect it in the event of the grantor's insolvency. Perfection typically occurs through:

1. Registration: Filing a financing statement on the Personal Property Securities Register (PPSR). This is the most common method.
2. Possession: The secured party taking physical possession of the collateral (applicable to certain tangible assets).
3. Control: The secured party gaining control over specific types of collateral, such as ADI accounts, investment instruments, and intermediated securities. Perfection by control often grants the highest level of priority.

The PPSA establishes detailed priority rules, generally favouring perfected security interests over unperfected ones. Between perfected interests, the rule is typically "first-in-time" based on registration, possession, or control. However, special rules apply, notably for Purchase Money Security Interests (PMSIs).

PPSA Complexities for Key Asset Classes

1. Shares (Investment Instruments)

• Classification: Shares are considered "personal property" and specifically "investment instruments" under the PPSA.
• Perfection: Security interests can be perfected by:
  • Control: This is the preferred method for priority. Control over certificated shares typically involves taking physical possession of share certificates along with blank executed share transfer forms. For uncertificated shares held through a clearing system like CHESS, control is achieved via arrangements with the relevant participant (e.g., a CHESS security deed).
  • Registration: Filing a financing statement on the PPSR is also possible but yields lower priority than perfection by control.
• Complexity: Ensuring the requirements for "control" are met precisely is critical for achieving priority, especially against competing interests.

2. Inventory (Tangible Movable Property)

• Classification: Inventory (stock-in-trade) is tangible movable property.
• Perfection: Typically perfected by registering a financing statement on the PPSR. Security over inventory often constitutes a "circulating security interest" (formerly a floating charge) over fluctuating assets.
• PMSIs: Security interests securing funds used to purchase specific inventory can qualify as PMSIs. If registered within strict timeframes (generally before the grantor obtains possession of the inventory), a PMSI can achieve "super priority" over prior-registered general security interests in the same inventory.
• Complexity: Correctly identifying inventory, meeting PMSI requirements (including specific description in the financing statement and timely registration), and managing the circulating nature of the asset are key challenges.

3. Bank Accounts (ADI Accounts)

• Classification: Accounts held with Authorised Deposit-taking Institutions (ADIs) are a specific class of collateral.
• Perfection:
  • Control: Achieved when the ADI holding the account is also the secured party, or through an Account Control Agreement (ACA) between the secured party, the grantor, and the ADI where the account is held. Perfection by control grants superior priority.
  • Registration: Possible, but yields lower priority.
• Complexity: Historically, obtaining ACAs from Australian ADIs (where the secured party is not the ADI itself) has been challenging, with many banks reluctant to enter into them. This often forces reliance on registration, which provides weaker protection, especially in insolvency.

4. Receivables (Debts, Contractual Rights)

• Classification: Includes trade debts, loans receivable, and other contractual rights to payment.
• Perfection: Primarily perfected by registration on the PPSR.
• PMSIs: Security interests securing funds used to acquire specific receivables can potentially qualify as PMSIs, offering super priority if registered correctly and timely.
• Assignment: An assignment of receivables can itself constitute a security interest requiring registration.
• Complexity: Ensuring accurate description of receivables in financing statements, managing collections, and navigating priority disputes (e.g., with suppliers claiming retention of title or PMSIs) are common issues.

5. Intellectual Property (IP)

• Classification: IP rights (patents, trademarks, copyrights, registered designs) are personal property.
• Perfection: Security interests over IP must be registered on the PPSR. Registration on specific IP registers (e.g., maintained by IP Australia) does not perfect the security interest under the PPSA, although it may be necessary for other reasons.
• Complexity: The PPSR registration provides priority under the PPSA framework, but enforcement often requires interaction with specific IP laws and registers. Accurately describing the specific IP rights in the PPSR registration is crucial.

6. Other Movable Assets (Equipment, Vehicles)

• Classification: Tangible movable property other than inventory.
• Perfection: Primarily perfected by registration on the PPSR. Specific rules apply to assets like motor vehicles, which may require registration by serial number for optimal priority.
• PMSIs: Security interests securing funds used to purchase specific equipment can qualify as PMSIs, offering super priority if registered within specific timeframes (generally within 15 business days after the grantor obtains possession).
• Complexity: Correct serial number identification and timely PMSI registration are critical for priority over equipment and vehicles.

Real Property vs. Personal Property

It's important to distinguish personal property (governed by the PPSA) from real property (land and fixtures, governed by state/territory land title laws). While a general security agreement might cover all assets, security over land requires a separate registered real property mortgage under the relevant Torrens system. A PPSR registration does not perfect a security interest in land itself, although it may cover fixtures before they become part of the land.

Financial Assistance & Other Restrictions

When taking security, particularly upstream or cross-stream security within a corporate group, lenders must consider the Corporations Act restrictions on financial assistance (Section 260A) and corporate benefit rules. Breaching these can render the security voidable. The "whitewash" procedure is a common workaround for financial assistance but involves specific shareholder approvals and ASIC lodgements.

Enforcement

The PPSA provides a range of enforcement remedies for secured parties, including seizure, retention (foreclosure), or disposal of collateral, often without needing court intervention. However, specific notice requirements and obligations to act commercially reasonably apply. Enforcement rights can be significantly impacted by the grantor entering voluntary administration or liquidation.

Conclusion

Navigating the PPSA requires careful attention to the specific type of asset being secured. Perfection by control offers the highest priority for certain asset classes like ADI accounts and investment instruments, while timely registration is key for others, especially when seeking PMSI super priority over inventory or equipment. Understanding the interplay between the PPSA, the Corporations Act, and specific asset characteristics is fundamental for structuring robust security packages in Australian private credit transactions. Seeking expert legal advice is essential to manage these complexities effectively.

Back to Insights